The Flames joined the Big South Conference in 1991. In the 21 seasons Liberty has participated in the Big South Conference Tournament, the Flames have reached the Semifinals on 11 occasions:
- 1992: L, 53-51 Campbell
- 1994: W, 63-58 Towson State – went on to win program’s 1st Big South title
- 1995: L, 60-58 Charleston Southern
- 1996: W, 73-60 UNC Asheville – lost in the championship game to UNC Greensboro
- 1997: W, 85-73 Radford – lost in the championship game to Charleston Southern
- 1998: L, 46-42 UNC Asheville
- 2001: L, 67-62 (2OT) Winthrop
- 2003: L, 55-52 Radford
- 2004: W, 88-73 Coastal Carolina – went on to win Big South title
- 2008: L, 75-57 UNC Asheville
- 2009: L, 78-58 VMI
With a win tonight against High Point, the Flames can make it 12 occasions in 22 seasons.
